Position pricing
A defensible mark on every position, including the ones with no market quote.
What you get
Section titled “What you get”| A mark on every position | Including LP tokens, concentrated-liquidity NFTs, yield tokens and vault shares, which have no quote to look up |
| Priced when it moved | Every movement valued as of its own transaction, not at a convenient month-end |
| A stated method | Which source produced each price, and the method where no source exists |
| A visible gap | Where no value can be derived, a labeled zero rather than a plausible number |
| Your source where it matters | A feed or a mark your policy or auditor requires, set with you |
Pricing sounds solved. Take the position, look up the price, multiply. It is solved, for the assets everybody demos on, and it is unsolved for a good number of the things a real fund holds, where the position has no venue, no quote and sometimes no obvious unit, and where the price you used is a judgment you will be defending to an auditor eight months from now.
Some positions have no price at all
Section titled “Some positions have no price at all”Some positions have no price at all. Not an illiquid price. No price. A concentrated-liquidity position is unique to its own token ID and there is no fungible market in it anywhere, so the price has to be constructed rather than fetched. A yield token’s value is definitionally a residual rather than a quote. A system built on the assumption that a price can always be fetched doesn’t degrade gracefully when it meets one of these. It either falls over, or it makes a number up.
The right source of a price changes over an asset’s life. A stablecoin is worth a dollar, right up until the day it isn’t, and holding it at par through that understates the loss and never triggers an impairment. A token that redeems at par after maturity trades at a discount before it. A token has no market at all until the day it lists. Tuesday’s correct answer is Wednesday’s wrong one, and the switch has to be known in advance rather than spotted in the data.
The price can be right and the position still wrong. Vault shares carry an exchange rate. Convert the shares into underlying units and then apply a price that already embeds the appreciation, and you’ve now applied that rate twice. Every check passes. The entry balances. The error just grows, quietly, by whatever the vault earned that day.
Not every “stablecoin” is a dollar. Yield-bearing dollar tokens are supposed to sit above par; they exist in order to. A book that hard-codes them at $1.00 is understating them by however much they’ve earned so far, and the gap widens every single day.
Constructing a price with no quote to start from
Section titled “Constructing a price with no quote to start from”This is the part people give up on, and I think it’s the most interesting problem in the whole business.
A concentrated-liquidity position doesn’t have a ticker. What it does have is a real, precise state sitting on-chain: its range, its liquidity, the pool’s current price. All of it is right there, and all of it is readable, if you’re willing to decode the contract and do the arithmetic rather than wait for a venue to publish a quote.
For those positions we don’t fetch a price. We derive one, from the position’s own on-chain parameters. Vault shares get the same treatment, using the exchange rate the contract itself reports, before anything gets priced.
Positions with no market quote at all, like an NFT-shaped loan or an illiquid unique asset, are a different problem and we treat them differently. The value has to be built from the position’s own terms, so we don’t invent anything either.
A loan note is worth its principal, in the asset that was actually borrowed, and when an illiquid thing genuinely sells, the sale price is the price. We take the real number over the estimate, because an estimate of a unique asset is a guess with a decimal point on it.
Where no value can be built, we book a zero and label it, rather than a plausible-looking number. A zero is ugly, but it’s visible, and your auditor will ask about it. A fabricated price is neither.
Priced at every transaction, not just at close
Section titled “Priced at every transaction, not just at close”This is the bit that matters more than it sounds like it does.
Most systems price your book at period end, because that’s when the report is due. Fine, as far as it goes, except that your positions don’t only exist at period end. You closed an LP position on the 14th. What price did your tool use for that disposal?
If the answer is the month-end price, or the last price it happened to have lying around, then your NAV might still look plausible while your realized gains are fiction, and realized gains get taxed. Your report is wrong, and so is your filing.
You cannot compute a realized gain at a price you never had, so we value each movement at its own transaction’s timestamp, when we parse it, to the hour. The disposal is priced when the disposal happened, not at a convenient time afterwards.
Then the price gets checked
Section titled “Then the price gets checked”A mark is worth what the position behind it is worth, so pricing hands off to the other half of the job: is the position in the book the position you hold? That question has its own page, reconciling the book to the chain, which also covers what happens to a difference when one turns up.
Worth knowing before you go there: a difference gets a reason attached rather than rounded into a fee line. A tool that books drift as yield to make an entry close has destroyed the evidence that something is wrong, and it keeps destroying it, month after month, until the gap is big enough to come and find you.